$5 and Under

84 products

    Affordable Cat-Themed Finds – Just $5 and Under!

    Discover Happy Little Kitty’s charming $5 and Under collection—a curated assortment of purr-fectly priced cat-themed gifts and accessories. Whether you’re shopping for whimsical kitty key covers, mini cookie cutters, cat earrings, or playful washi tape, these budget-friendly picks deliver fun and feline flair at unbeatable prices. Ideal for stocking stuffers, small surprises, or budget-conscious gifting.

    Browse now and delight in cute, affordable cat-themed treasures—without breaking the bank!

    84 products
    Sale
    Cat-Themed Washi Tape set featuring various playful cat designs for crafts
    Modern black cats in stretching poses washi tape
    Cat Themed Washi Tape
    Save $3.99
    Sale
    Coffee Spoon- Black - Happy Little Kitty
    Coffee Spoon- Rainbow - Happy Little Kitty
    Coffee Spoon – Stylish, Stainless & Cat-Lover Approved
    Save $4.99
    Sale
    Cat Head Binder Clips - Happy Little Kitty
    Cat Head Binder Clips
    Save $1.99
    Sale
    Black Cat Fruit Forks - Happy Little Kitty
    Black Cat Fruit Forks – Cute Reusable Snack & Appetizer Picks for Cat Lovers (Set of 12)
    Save $5.99
    Sale
    Leather Cat Luggage Tag with embossed cat design and buckle strap
    Genuine leather luggage tag featuring a playful embossed cat silhouette
    Leather Cat Luggage Tag
    Save $4.99
    Sale
    Glitter Cat Head Earring- Black - Happy Little Kitty
    Glitter Cat Head Earring- Black
    Save $6.99
    Sale
    Sweet Kitty Cookie Cutter - Happy Little Kitty
    Sweet Kitty Cookie Cutter
    Save $4.99
    Sale
    Adjustable Cat Ring- Silver - Happy Little Kitty
    Adjustable Cat Ring- Silver - Happy Little Kitty
    Adjustable Cat Ring – Chic, Comfortable & Cat-Lover Approved!
    Save $4.99
    Sale
    Calico cat silicone key cover for standard keys, cat-themed accessory
    Cat Key Cover- Calico
    Save $2.99
    Sale
    Hold Your Kitties! Adhesive Cat Hooks- Black - Happy Little Kitty
    Hold Your Kitties! Adhesive Cat Hooks- Black - Happy Little Kitty
    Hold Your Kitties! Adhesive Cat Hooks- Black
    Save $2.99
    Sale
    Cute Kitty Cookie Cutter - Happy Little Kitty
    Cute Kitty Cookie Cutter
    Save $4.99
    Sale
    I'm Purrfect Makeup Bag - Happy Little Kitty
    I'm Purrfect Makeup Bag
    Save $4.99
    Sale
    Sparkly Kitty Rhinestone Keychain - Happy Little Kitty
    Sparkly Kitty Rhinestone Keychain
    Save $4.99
    Sale
    Creative Cats Pencil Bag- White - Happy Little Kitty
    Creative Cats Pencil Bag- White
    Save $4.99
    Sale
    Glitter Cat Head Earring- Silver - Happy Little Kitty
    Glitter Cat Head Earring- Silver
    Save $6.99
    Sale
    Black Cat Earring - Happy Little Kitty
    Black Cat Earring
    Save $6.99
    Sale
    Cat Wrap Ring - Happy Little Kitty
    Cat Wrap Ring
    Save $4.99
    Sale
    Paws Off Makeup Bag - Happy Little Kitty
    Paws Off Makeup Bag - Happy Little Kitty
    Paws Off Makeup Bag
    Save $7.99
    Sale
    Hair Clip – Gold with cat-inspired design, stylish accessory for cat lovers
    Hair Clip- Gold
    Save $6.99
    Sale
    Rhinestone Ring- Silver - Happy Little Kitty
    Rhinestone Ring
    Save $4.99
    Sale
    cat ear flannel headband elastic bottom
    You Look Meow-Velous! Headband
    Save $6.99
    Sale
    Petite Cat Earring - Happy Little Kitty
    Petite Cat Earring
    Save $6.99
    Sale
    Detail of gray tabby cat face on Cat Key Cover – Gray Tabby
    Cat Key Cover- Gray Tabby
    Save $2.99
    Sale
    Cat Ear Card Wallet - Happy Little Kitty
    Cat Ear Card Wallet
    Save $3.99
    Sale
    Cat Hair Tie Loop with cute cat charm, durable elastic hair accessory
    Detail of cat charm on Cat Hair Tie Loop
    Cat Hair Tie Loop
    Save $1.99
    Sale
    Hair Clip- Silver - Happy Little Kitty
    Hair Clip- Silver
    Save $2.99
    Sale
    Cat Head Wooden Metric Ruler- Brown - Happy Little Kitty
    Cat Head Wooden Metric Ruler- Brown - Happy Little Kitty
    Cat Head Wooden Metric Ruler- Brown
    Save $2.99
    Sale
    Durable silver metal adhesive cat hook with playful feline silhouette
    Hold Your Kitties! Adhesive Cat Hooks- Silver - Happy Little Kitty
    Hold Your Kitties! Adhesive Cat Hooks- Silver
    Save $2.99
    Sale
    Adjustable pearl cat ring with charming feline motif, polished alloy finish
    Pearl Cat Ring
    Save $4.99
    Sale
    pop up card
    Save $2.99
    Sale
    Tie Dye Paw Print Makeup Bag
    Save $9.99
    Sale
    Peace, Love, Paws Makeup Bag
    Save $9.99
    Sale
    Drink Coffee, Pet Cats Makeup Bag
    Save $9.99
    Sale
    Siamese cat silicone key cover with blue eyes and brown ears
    Cat Key Cover- Siamese
    Save $2.99
    Sale
    Cat Moon Pendant - Happy Little Kitty
    Cat Moon Pendant
    Save $2.99
    Sale
    Opal Cat Body Earrings – White, cat silhouette jewelry for cat lovers
    Opal Cat Body Earrings- White
    Save $6.99
    Sale
    Cat Head Wooden Metric Ruler- Black - Happy Little Kitty
    Cat Head Wooden Metric Ruler- Black - Happy Little Kitty
    Cat Head Wooden Metric Ruler
    Save $2.99
    Sale
    Paw Print Balloons featuring cat paw print designs, 12 inches, pack of 10, shown fully inflated for party decoration
    Paw Print Balloons
    Save $4.99
    Sale
    Opal Cat Body Earrings- Pink - Happy Little Kitty
    Opal Cat Body Earrings- Pink
    Save $6.99
    Sale
    Cat Felt Mouse Pad - Happy Little Kitty
    Cat Felt Mouse Pad
    Save $8.99
    Recently viewed